Traumatic Posterior Hip Dislocation in a 5-Year-Old: A Case Report and Review of the Literature
Adam D. Bitterman, DO (Orthopaedic Surgery Resident)1
Francisco Javier Laplaza, MD (Pediatric Orthopaedic Surgery Attending)2
Shalin Shah, OMS IV (Medical Student)3
1Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, North Shore / Long Island Jewish: Plainview Hospital, Plainview, NY 11803, USA
2Department of Pediatric Orthopaedic Surgery, North Shore / Long Island Jewish: Cohen Children’s Medical Center, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA
3New York Institute of Technology College of Osteopathic Medicine, Old Westbury, NY 11568, USA
Correspondence: Adam D. Bitterman, DO, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Department of Medical Education, NS/LIJ Plainview Hospital, 888 Old Country Road, 25 Building, Plainview, NY 11803, Ph: (516) 719-2546, Fax: (516) 719-2766
Email: Adam.Bitterman@gmail.com, Cell Phone: (631) 831-5211
No financial support was provided for this manuscript. The authors deny any conflicts of interest associated with this case report.
Traumatic hip dislocations in children are uncommon, yet constitute an orthopaedic emergency. Furthermore, the insignificant mechanism of injury oftentimes leads to a potential miss or delay in diagnosis. The nature of the injury may seem minor so as to not pursue further workup. For this reason it is imperative to have a high index of suspicion, as clinical assessment and judicious imaging are key to obtaining the patient’s correct diagnosis. Although there are various complications that may result from such an injury, the most commonly encountered and most catastrophic is avascular necrosis (AVN), of the femoral head; early concentric reduction is crucial in minimizing this risk and optimizing patient outcomes.
This is a case of a 5-year-old, Caucasian male with no significant medical history, who presented with severe left hip pain as well as a deformed left lower extremity. His parents reported that he was playing with his cousin when he suddenly fell and was no longer to able to bear weight on his left leg.
Upon physical examination his left lower extremity was flexed at the hip, internally rotated and slightly adducted. He had no sensory or motor deficits and his pulses were palpable at the dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial arteries. His foot was warm and well-perfused. Radiographic evaluation of the pelvis and hip demonstrated a posterior native hip dislocation without any obvious fractures.
He was taken to the operating room emergently where general anesthesia was initiated. Using fluoroscopy the left hip was reduced using gentle manipulation. Post-procedural radiographs confirmed the reduction and demonstrated a concentric left hip joint. A well-padded one-and-a-half leg hip spica was applied for additional stability.
He was discharged home on post-procedural day two after appropriate arrangements for home care and home schooling were coordinated. He remained in the spica cast for a total of four weeks. Upon his most recent follow-up, approximately 6 weeks from his injury, he is ambulating with a slight limp but has no ill effects from his native left hip dislocation.
The disabling effects of a dislocated hip in children were clearly described by Hippocrates circa 400 BC, but its etiology was poorly understood3. The rare nature of this injury was subsequently documented in 1922, when a review of all hip dislocations treated at the Rizzoli Orthopedic Institute revealed only 3 pediatric cases out of a total 1,84213. As in adults, traumatic hip dislocations in children are most often posterior in nature, with a clear predominance of male individuals9,20. Many of these patients present with the classic clinical picture of a shortened limb with the hip flexed, adducted, and internally rotated. It is important to note that the patient may present exclusively with referred knee pain, demonstrating a need for suspicion of underlying hip pathology4,18. With regards to radiographic evaluation, anteroposterior (AP), and cross-table lateral radiographs can detect the majority of cases. Additionally, these images are well-tolerated, readily available, and show the relevant osseous anatomy4,8.
Of the potential complications, the most commonly encountered and also the most catastrophic is avascular necrosis of the femoral head. Although necrotic bone was described as far back as 400 B.C., early medical literature only recognized it in the setting of osteomyelitis. The first case report of AVN, attributed particularly to disruption of blood flow, was subsequently documented in 1870 by Francis Paget2. The basis of the repair of such osteonecrotic bone came to light several decades later in 1930, where Phemister et al. concluded that the contact of necrotic bone with living bone stimulates an ingrowth of vessels and osteogenic tissue into the dead tissue16.
AVN is defined by the death of bone tissue due to a lack of blood supply. In the case of hip dislocations, the medial and lateral femoral circumflex arteries are susceptible to such disruption. Radiographs may not show evidence of necrosis for several weeks, however, MRI and bone scan can be used for earlier detection. Interestingly, a review of several cases show that the changes noted on radiographs are strikingly similar to those of Legg-Calve-Perthes disease; this refers to the sclerosis, initial flattening of the epiphysis, along with early fragmentation4,9,12,18.
The significance of early reduction is stressed by studies that showed the incidence of AVN rises to over 65%, from the average 8-10%, if reduction is delayed 24 hours after dislocation6,18. The classic report by Mehlman et al. concluded that patients whose hips were reduced more than 6 hours after injury had a 20-fold increase in the risk of developing avascular necrosis15. Moreover, AVN may develop up to 3 years after the inciting injury4. Delays in diagnosis are commonly encountered not only due to the rarity and minimal amount of trauma that may be involved, but also to the presence of other injuries that may divert attention from the hip injury12,20.
Several reports confirm that there is a direct correlation between AVN and time to reduction rather than with time to weight bearing. It is important to note that a reduction in less than 6 hours does not preclude the risk of avascular necrosis4. This is supported by Chung’s study on normal hips depicting that 23% of autopsied children had incomplete anastomotic networks and only 1.3% had transepiphyseal vessels5. Other complications that are not as commonly encountered but important to keep in mind include myositis ossificans, post-traumatic osteoarthritis, premature physeal fusion, and sciatic nerve injury7.
Incidences and Outcomes
The relatively rare nature of pediatric hip dislocations is depicted by the fact that they consist of less than 5% of all traumatic hip dislocations, including those in adults4,7. The immature skeleton of a child predisposes itself to such injuries from both clear and seemingly unremarkable mechanisms. The provoking event may range from simple playground activities, to competitive sports. Several studies stratified the patient populations into two groups, younger and older, with the magnitude of force producing the injury shown to increase with age. The younger group, ranging from 2 to 8 years of age, yielded dislocations from lower energy trauma compared to those in the older group, which was defined as older than 10 years of age7,17,19. This difference was attributed to the greater degree of ligamentous laxity in younger children. With increasing age, joint laxity decreases, and growth cartilage calcifies resulting in a diminished cartilage to bone ratio6,9,12,14,20. For this reason, children also have fewer associated injuries compared to adults, who commonly present with concomitant acetabular fractures. This provides us with reasoning that older children may sustain associated fractures compared to the younger pediatric population with greater bone plasticity. Considering this population’s exquisite remodeling potential, if managed in a timely manner, the outcomes are markedly favorable and many patients may continue to participate in high intensity activities.
Prompt closed reduction under general anesthesia is key to the patient’s long-term prognosis, ideally within 6 hours of the inciting injury. The significance of a concentric reduction is based on the concept that proper anatomic placement serves as a stimulus for growth of the pelvis and the femur. This prevents deformity and maintains proper limb length6. Muscular relaxation may also be crucial, as older children are at risk for fracturing their physis with such reduction maneuvers9. Additionally, pain management is essential, and a quick and effective method reported for use in the emergency department is intranasal fentanyl administration4.
The maneuvers used for closed reduction in adult dislocations can be utilized for pediatric patients as well, including the Allis, Bigelow, and Stimson maneuvers4,14. It has also been suggested that aspiration of the joint after closed reduction should be done to drain the hemarthrosis in an attempt to improve the vascular supply and decrease capsular distention17. If closed reduction cannot be achieved after one or two attempts, then open reduction should be performed4,6. Furthermore, interposition of particular structures such as labrum, capsule, or osteochondral fragments may limit a complete reduction. This would manifest as articular widening and incongruency on post-reduction radiographs, which also requires surgical intervention9,19. Additional indications for surgical exploration and intervention include associated fractures of the femoral neck or acetabulum, and those patients that present late. As each minute delays a favorable prognosis, many of these patients are almost guaranteed to have avascular necrosis. Nonetheless, there is still significant functional improvement following operative intervention4,12. An analysis by Hung suggests that if the patient presents over 3 weeks after a dislocation, the surgical intervention may include releasing the adductor longus, lengthening the psoas tendon, and inserting a Kirschner wire to secure the hip into the joint10. If both closed and open reductions fail, salvage procedures including arthrodesis, osteotomy, and excisional arthroplasty are additional options in managing these patients1,12.
It is important to follow up the hip reduction with quality radiographs. Not only does this allow for comparing congruency between joint spaces, but also rules out fractures or other conditions that may further interfere with the patient’s recovery14,20. A post-reduction joint space asymmetry of 3 mm or greater is an indication for a CT scan4,15. Although there have been no definitive conclusions, several studies have proven that 6 weeks of immobilization in a spica cast is sufficient to precede weight bearing of the affected limb14,20.
Our case presentation emphasizes the importance of maintaining a high degree of suspicion when evaluating a child with a potential hip injury – especially because traumatic dislocations are 25 times less common in children than in adults6,12. As children are active by nature, their immature skeletons predispose them to this orthopaedic emergency. There seems to be a proportional increase in the force necessary to cause dislocation with increasing age4,9,19. Having a familiarity with management is key to improving patient prognosis and limiting further morbidity. Timely reduction, ideally within 6 hours of the inciting injury, is the standard used to prevent the disabling complications, of greatest importance being avascular necrosis of the femoral head.
- Banskota AK, Spiegel DA, Shrestha S, Shrestha OP, Rajbhandary T. Open reduction for neglected traumatic hip dislocation in children and adolescents. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics. 2007;27(2):187-191.
- Bishop AT, Pelzer M. Avascular Necrosis. In: Berger R, Weiss A et al. Hand Surgery. Based on: Hand Surgery 1st ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2004. http://www.msdlatinamerica.com/ebooks/HandSurgery/sid428276.html. Accessed March 16, 2014.
- Bowen JR, Kotzias-Neto A. Introduction-disease history of DDH. In: Developmental dysplasia of the hip. Based on: Bowen JR, Kotzias-Neto A, 1st ed. Brooklandville, MD: Data Trace Publishing Company; 2006. http://hipdysplasia.org/for-physicians/online-textbook-of-hip-dysplasia/. Accessed March 16, 2014.
- Bressan S, Steiner IP, Shavit I. Emergency department diagnosis and treatment of traumatic hip dislocations in children under the age of 7 years: a 10-year review. Emergency Medicine Journal. 2013.
- Chung SM: The arterial supply of the developing proximal end of the human femur. J Bone Joint Surg 58A: 961-970, 1976
- Coll GF, Del Rio LT, Nuño LG, Burniol JR, Carol RH. Traumatic hip dislocation in childhood. Hip International. 2010;20(4).
- Hamilton PR, Broughton NS. Traumatic hip dislocation in childhood. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics. 1998;18(5):691-694.
- Haverstock JP, Sanders DW, Bartley DL, Lim RK. Traumatic Pediatric Hip Dislocation in a Toddler. Journal of Emergency Medicine, The. 2013;45(1):91-94.
- Herrera-Soto JA, Price CT. Traumatic hip dislocations in children and adolescents: pitfalls and complications. Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. 2009;17(1):15-21.
- Hung NN. Traumatic hip dislocation in children. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics B. 2012;21(6):542-551.
- Kumar JN, Hazra S, Yun HH. Redislocation after treatment of traumatic dislocation of hip in children: a report of two cases and literature review. Archives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery. 2009;129(6):823-826.
- Kumar S, Jain AK. Neglected traumatic hip dislocation in children. Clinical orthopaedics and related research. 2005;431:9-13.
- Mason ML: Traumatic dislocation of the hip in childhood: Report of a case. J Bone Joint Surg 36B: 630-632, 1954.
- Meena S, Kishanpuria T, Gangari SK, Sharma P. Traumatic posterior hip dislocation in a 16-month-old child: a case report and review of literature. Chinese Journal of Traumatology. 2012;15(6):382-384.
- Mehlman CT, Hubbard GW, Crawford AH, Roy DR, Wall EJ. Traumatic hip dislocation in children: Long-term follow-up of 42 patients. Clinical orthopaedics and related research. 2000;376:68-79.
- Phemister DB. Repair of bone in the presence of aseptic necrosis resulting from fractures, transplantations and vascular obstruction. J Bone Joint Surg 1930; 12:769- 787.
- Reiger H, Penning D, Klein W, Grunert J: Traumatic dislocations of the hip in young children. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 110: 114-117, 1991.
- Singhal R, Perry D, Cohen D, Bruce C. Reminder of important clinical lesson: Delayed diagnosis of traumatic hip dislocation mimicking Perthes disease in a child. BMJ case reports. 2011;2011.
- Vialle R, Odent T, Pannier S, Pauthier F, Laumonier F, Glorion C. Traumatic hip dislocation in childhood. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics. 2005;25(2):138-144.
- Zrig M, Mnif H, Koubaa M, Abid A. Traumatic hip dislocation in children. Acta Orthopaedica Belgica. 2009;75(3):328.